ER casework practical cases. Help!

Hello, Keith, and thank you so much for your answer. Please see my example below.

A school cleaner who did not turn up to work. His line-manager calls him and he does not answer or return call. Eventually the cleaner gets back to line-manager and says he’s gone to Brazil for 2 weeks to care for his wife after surgery.

I am tasked with the investigation and line-manager tells me the cleaner asked a month ago to take 2 weeks leave during summer and line-manager said no.

He is a great cleaner with great attendance and no previous issues. However, as soon as he returns he is interviewed by me and he brings proof of wife’s elective surgery; a letter is sent to him inviting him to a disciplinary meeting for gross misconduct, that is, not attending work when should have, not following procedure to report absence and not following reasonable instructions from line-manager.

The meeting is held and he is dismissed for gross misconduct.

How could I improve this, Keith? Thank you in advance.

Hello, Keith, and thank you so much for your answer. Please see my example below.

A school cleaner who did not turn up to work. His line-manager calls him and he does not answer or return call. Eventually the cleaner gets back to line-manager and says he’s gone to Brazil for 2 weeks to care for his wife after surgery.

I am tasked with the investigation and line-manager tells me the cleaner asked a month ago to take 2 weeks leave during summer and line-manager said no.

He is a great cleaner with great attendance and no previous issues. However, as soon as he returns he is interviewed by me and he brings proof of wife’s elective surgery; a letter is sent to him inviting him to a disciplinary meeting for gross misconduct, that is, not attending work when should have, not following procedure to report absence and not following reasonable instructions from line-manager.

The meeting is held and he is dismissed for gross misconduct.

How could I improve this, Keith? Thank you in advance.

Hi Sandra

Thanks for the extra information. This is either a very simple case or has some of the elements of a more complex one and everything will come down to how you explain it. The question in an interview is there to see if you understand the nuances of ER cases (which are hard to get across in simple text book examples) and how you think about them. Drawing these out in your explanation with show you can analyse and deal with more complex cases.

So not suggesting this is a perfect answer but with the same facts...

1. The initial case appeared to be a simply AWOL case. School Cleaner failed to attend work for a few days. Advised Manager to attempt to make contact in line with AWOL policy largely at this stage to check employee was Ok.Employee was previously of good character and no serious issues on file.
   
   
2. Employe gets in touch and says he has returned to Brazil to look after sick wife. Discuss case with manager. Sympathetic given personal circumstances but has left a serious gap in rotas at a busy time and with COVID need for cleaners paramount. Discussed disciplinary options with manager and potentially might be a final written warning on return given mitigation of sick wife
3. Further investigation shows employee had requested 2 weeks leave (for same period) which had been refused. Turns case in to one of potential dishonesty and escalates seriousness. Mitigation probably wouldn't carry as much weight given pre-planned nature  of leave.
   
   
4. Advised Manager to hold an investigation on employees return. Considered suspension but did / didn't go ahead because...
5.  Investigation held and there was proof of wife surgery. He was / wasn't aware of the reporting requirements etc
   
   
6. At the disciplinary we considered his mitigation (wife illness) his previous good work conduct but felt that due to his fundamental dishonesty we had no option to dismiss. 

All the same facts just set out in a more structured way and considering options alternatives at each stage.

 DO you have perhaps other examples that are more nuanced? Ones perhaps that involve multiple people are often good and situations where  actions have either gone on over some time (the above is a little open and shut) or involve several versions of the facts that you have had to balance to make a decision.

Bullying and harassment cases often make good examples. Or ones where there is absence, disciplinaries and also grievances all in the mix to varying degrees. 

Hope the above helps. Let me know your thoughts