3

Is emigration the best solution if one has difficulties in getting jobs in the UK?

Whether one relocates to another EU country such as Belgium, or a non EU country such as the USA, is the HR jobs market largely the same worldwide, samely competitive, with employers looking for the closest tick box person specification match and fit on all the essentials and desirables? HR, unlike the Stem and medical professions, is not in global skills shortage demand that they would actively look to bring people in from elsewhere. 

Add into the mix language, lack of national qualifications and localised experience, immigratIon and visa issues outside of the EU, knowledge and understanding of the labour laws there, and it can suddenly become to look far more challenging than one faces at home. 

Thus, whether a UK HR Practitioner wishes to relocate to work in Brussels or Los Angeles, what are typically the logistical complexities involved, can most people actually do or pull off a career move of that nature in practice (or is in impossible in both relative / absolute terms) or are the vast majority already on or in a senior level role in the UK and either transferred by existing organisations in the UK, their target country or headhunted in advance by an international executive search boutique?  

What could be difficult at home could be 5 times more demanding elsewhere as you are also not one of them who tend to get first preference in their jobs market.

I have always believed that if one wishes to succeed career wise outside of their home country and / or home regional operating market, i.e. UK & Ireland, EU and EMEA, you first need to be able to build, show and demonstrate a certain career track record of success at home. Otherwise, if you cannot do, hack it or have what it takes to first work yourself up into a certain position at home where you have all the immediate advantages such as language, right to work, education and experience, it will be even more difficult trying to do it aboard in another country. If one cannot get an HRBP role in London, why would they suddenly obtain one in New York?     

I also understand the USA who only wants the creme de la creme and best of the best from around the world, one would typically need to be a Chartered Fellow with 5+ years of progressive experience to get in there. They would not facilitate a transfer for an HR Administrator as local candidates fill those roles.  

There is a very good saying in life that one may change the skies they are under and soil they are on, but are essentially the same person as you cannot just alter your personality, professional profile and conjure up new and more experience overnight. It's a gradual process.      

Therefore and in closing, if one has difficulties in getting jobs in the UK, could the same problems just follow them elsewhere, or follow them in a slightly different form, but that would perhaps be for new and different reasons as well, with cultural also added into the mix?

Does a global HR market also exist, but one needs to be at the very top of the profession to partake in that?    

938 views
  • By and large in most countries employers will only consider local staff for admin or support roles; skills are easily acquired there is no shortage of candidates.

    At profession, specialist and more senior levels most HR jobs call for specific local knowledge (employment law, employee relations law , tax and social security law for benefits and payroll, intimate knowledge of local labour market and education system). Without this specific knowledge and a sound appreciation of local culture and interpersonal behavioural practices/values, getting a professional or senior job will be very difficult - with the exception perhaps of talent/career development where it is possible to get by on demonstrated soft interpersonal skils in addition to the talent /development skills (more easily transferable).

    At the very top of the profession it is entirely possible to have international moves - I've worked with Group HR Directors of several nationalities in the large (100,000+staff) in which I have worked - these jobs have generally been filled internally and call more more management/strategy skills because they have people in their teams who possess the top level speciality skills (international comp & ben, international employee relations etc).
  • In addition to Rays excellent and practical advice I would add a few thoughts:

    1. A lot of HR is about culture and this is very different in different countries. Whilst some areas of Hr may be more easily transferred (ie Comp & Ben possibly) many others require a complex and deep understanding of the local culture and this is probably far harder than language skills to pick up.

    2. It would be a mistake to assume that other countries have far easier HR job markets and are desperate to recruit UK HR bods to fill their roles. It simply isnt the case, leaving aside the complexities of getting visas / work permits etc unless you have a skill that can not be recruited locally then its unlikely they will go to the time and trouble of taking a risk on an out of country candidate (unless you already have experience in their labour market)

    3. Anybody (general comment) who is looking to move needs to be sure that the personal/skills/competency  factors that are holding them back in developing a HR career in the UK won't be exactly the same in holding them back overseas on top of the challenges of operating with cultures/laws and practices that they are unfamiliar with

    4. Its worth noting that while we still have a long way to go , the UK perhaps is more advanced   than many countries in recognising the opportunities and challenges of employing people with disabilities generally and certainly probably a few years ahead (but still not very good) of employing neuro-diverse people. It would be a mistake to assume every country has the same approaches.
  • And a lot of countries with points systems will likely mean a qualified welder is likely to score more points than a qualified HR person. 15 years ago Mrs P and myself fancied moving to Canada for a few years. No chance! Too old (over 50 mean minus 10 points. Didn't speak French - thats another minus 10 points. Over 10 years experience in HR +Qual, that got 2 points.

    But a Chinese qualified welder under 30 year old would have instantly got him/her a total of 30 points. (They didn't ask if you spoke English!).

    So a change of career my get you abroad. Ever fancy welding? ;-)