What do you value more in a candidate: education, experience and/or attitude?

This piece on the BBC caught our attention this morning. More students than ever are earning undergraduate degrees and more people are taking on second degrees but perhaps still lack hands on experience (including in HR). 

Two degrees now needed to get higher pay - BBC

Some time ago Rachel asked: “if you could take just one more qualification what would it be...?” and a few people suggested a Masters in HR. Keith added that “HR people [could] always benefit from a good understanding of finance.”

Or should we disregard educational qualifications in the recruitment process entirely? 

As Keith said on that particular thread:

"There is no magic answer that will open the doors to a HR career for you. As with all careers it’s a combination of hard work, luck, qualifications, experience and being in the right place at the right time."

What do you value more in a candidate: education, experience and/or attitude?

Parents
  • Working in a software company I mainly recruit software developers. For me personally, I value experience and attitude equally. From experience I have found that someone can finish uni with a 1st class honours which don't get me wrong is very impressive, however, that does not mean they are going to be the best software developer. Following the initial CV review, we ask all candidates to take part in a coding challenge and this is where I have seen people, who, on paper should be brilliant but haven't been able to complete the challenge or even come close to the answer. Attitude is also so important as we are a small globally distributed team. If someone doesn't have the right attitude it can have a huge impact on morale. I agree with Nina when she wrote that attitude is hardest to add if it is not there to start with.
Reply
  • Working in a software company I mainly recruit software developers. For me personally, I value experience and attitude equally. From experience I have found that someone can finish uni with a 1st class honours which don't get me wrong is very impressive, however, that does not mean they are going to be the best software developer. Following the initial CV review, we ask all candidates to take part in a coding challenge and this is where I have seen people, who, on paper should be brilliant but haven't been able to complete the challenge or even come close to the answer. Attitude is also so important as we are a small globally distributed team. If someone doesn't have the right attitude it can have a huge impact on morale. I agree with Nina when she wrote that attitude is hardest to add if it is not there to start with.
Children
No Data