7

Will my lack of a degree hold me back in HR?

Hi all, I am currently in the process of changing career from a primarily management role with HR responsibilities to an HR role. I am 21 next month and have a level 3 certificate in human resource practice along with a level 5 NVQ in management in a health and social care role (my current job.) Unfortunately though as I did not attend University I have some concerns about how the lack of a degree may affect my potential to progress down a HR career. I would be interested in completing either the Level 5 or Level 7 Diplomas in HR when I am in a pure HR role and have the funds to self finance but am unsure if employers consider these as suitable replacements for having a degree for the roles where this is required. 

If not are there any alternative routes to achieving a relevant degree? I know that the open university offers some courses in HR and business degrees but would be concerned about spending 4+ years on this after the time required to achieve my other CIPD qualifications. Is there any way that I could use completion of the Level 7 to contribute towards a Degree?

Through my current role I have developed a strong passion for HR and would like a clear plan for progression, both in my career and in my qualifications.

Thanks in advance for any replies

1225 views
  • Your main challenge will be getting your first job in HR. It will be tough with no direct experience and yes you will be up against candidates with degrees. WIll it hold you back? Well a little but not hugely.

    In time you should aim for level 5 and then level 7 and then convert level 7 to a Masters and then you will be on a level playing field.

    I am sure there are lots of HR people who get on without a first degree - many people come into profession from support or admin roles. But I think this is getting less than it used to.
  • The people I know that work in HR have a come from a mix of backgrounds. I've seen people get on with degrees, but then have also seen someone get on without a degree or any other qualifications. I've also seen someone get into HR as an Apprentice and then became an HR Officer.

    A lot of the jobs I've seen recently do ask for a degree level education or equivalent, so I'd say you already have the HR experience already. Personally, I have one of the most important things is confidence.
  • I have worked in retail management for almost 20 years with some HR responsibilities, knowing this was the path I wanted to go down and no development opportunities within the organisation I worked for, I was lucky enough to secure a HR officer role and I am now working towards my Level 7. If you find an organisation that supports the L&D of the individuals then you will achieve everything you want to achieve.
    Wishing you the best of luck
    Louisa
  • Personally speaking, I think experience counts for a lot more than a degree. I have a degree in a totally unrelated field so it was no help to me at all. I've worked with people who have completed a degree in Personnel Management but have no experience and not a clue how to apply their learning.

    I did my CPP and my Level 7, I learned the theory but they didn't teach me about the practice of HR. I learned that from working in HR. I started as an HR administrator and was fortunate to work with managers who were willing to share their knowledge with me. The most valuable thing for me was the mistakes I made, you learn very quickly not to make them again.

    As Keith says, it is hard to get your first position in HR, be prepared to take a step down if necessary. I'm glad I did as it gave me a good grounding and understanding.
  • In reply to Caroline:

    I think the point may be though not that your "degree" per se is useful but having one is a selection/short listing criteria for many jobs now. Even in many HR Shared services Centres now virtually all the staff have degrees
  • In reply to Keith:

    You are probably right! It's a shame to use that as a measure though because with the high cost of tuition fees and the prospect of large student debts, a lot of talented people are choosing not to go to university.
  • In reply to Caroline:

    I don't disagree - but it is so often used as a short listing method