Value of previous management experience when transferring into HR

Hello,

Apologies that this is a somewhat lengthy post, but I need to provide you with some context...

I have 25 years' experience working in professional services businesses (ones where we sell individual's time and skills - where without good/motivated people, we were nothing).  The last 15 years I have held Senior Management responsibility - everything from business strategy, talent management, business development, etc, but none of this has been in a formal HR capacity.  In essence I was responsible for $14 million turnover and a team of 65+ people.  From a quasi HR perspective, I was involved in succession planning, recruitment, training & development, retention, employee engagement, line managing and coaching, internal communications and supporting the business through large organisational change.  However, I do not have any formal HR training and have never held a HR role.

I have a business degree (but it was some time ago now!) with a specialisation in Marketing. 

I want to transition into HR - I'm less interested in the areas of employment law, remuneration/benefits, grievances, etc and more interested in Recruitment & talent planning, Employee engagement, Learning/Training/Development, Organisational development/change.  In essence, the parts of HR that support people in reaching strategic business objectives and support the business in encouraging people to reach their potential.

So...after having a year off work I now need to plan my next steps.  I am considering the Level 5 Diploma in HR Management - My thoughts are that this would give me good grounding in all the areas of HR.  I understand that I can do this online and can apply myself pretty much full time to complete the programme in 7-9 months.  

The plan would then be to secure a HR Manager role (I expect this would be a decrease in salary and a lower level of responsibility than I am used to) in an organisation that would hopefully fund my level 7 and set me on a path for growth into a more strategic HR capacity.  Am I dreaming?

I need insight from senior HR leaders...would the combination of my business experience and a level 5 diploma be attractive to an employer who is looking for a HR Manager with ambition to develop?  I don't want to undertake the training to find that without previous formal HR experience, I am not attractive to employers.

Any guidance is gratefully received.  Two related questions:

- I have discounted the Level 7 course because I don't have formal HR experience.  Would you agree?

- For those who have taken the level 5 diploma - am i at a disadvantage given that I'm not currently working and unable to put theory into practice whilst studying?

If you've made it this far...Thank You.  All advice gratefully received.

Karen

Parents Reply Children
  • Thanks for your response Anna. I hear what you are saying and I haven't started trying to find a role in HR yet. My perception is that there is a bit of a catch 22 here...you suggest "finding the HR role first and then deciding on which qualification is appropriate"...from what I can see, the qualification is often a pre-requisite for the role?? Can you recommend any HR recruiters in the NorthWest that I should contact for further discussion?
    Thanks again,
    Karen
  • Keith has said much of what I would be saying Karen. There is always value in having a CIPD qualification, but it's not a golden key to a job. And I fear you may be very disappointed if you go that route and find you still cannot get work in HR - which is why we're suggesting you test the waters first.

    Doing so will also help you further clarify your commitment to HR as you navigate the recruitment process.

    Yes, most ads do ask for a qualification and as I pointed out in the other thread it's a way to weed out some of the large number of applications. That doesn't mean you must have one - provided you can demonstrate experience that will be of value to a prospective employer. I'm not a great fan of summary paragraphs at the start of CVs but in your case I'd make an exception and suggest you do put one in the states while you don't currently have a qualification you consider your previous extensive experience to be relevant and of value (or something along those lines).

    I'm not familiar with HR recruiters in the north west, but would suggest you talk with some of the bigger HR specialist agencies. I'd also recommend going to branch events and networking with people already in HR who may be able to give you further feedback.
  • Thank you Anna. This makes perfect sense.