35

Any tips for private sector HR professional interviewing for first public sector?

Hello all, 

I have worked in HR for 17 years, always in the private sector, mostly hospitality and retail, although I have spent the last 3 years heading the HR function in a medium-sized tech company, a business unit of a larger group. I now want to move into the Public Sector and have an interview on Tuesday for an HR department head role. I am very excited about this. My reasons for wanting to move after all these years are two-fold: 

1. I have had enough of the sometimes greedy mindset of our company's C-suite. I fully understand it is all about profit but there is often very little consideration for the people. Put it this way, they are constantly praising the staff, sending thank-you emails etc. but our benefits are minimal (i.e. statutory maternity / paternity pay, no 'death in service' - last time we asked we were told it was a 'no', as they did not offer this across the Group, and had no plans to). When I spoke about our current initiative to measure - and respond to - employee sentiment - the CEO called it 'bollocks'! Now seeing him rock up in his Porche SUV and doing the royal walk round (when I know he does not care for the people) is really rankling. In other words, I am looking for a greater sense of purpose. Something that is not all about money. Again, I get it, that is the nature of business but I have experienced many unethical businesses now and would like a change. 

2. I will be honest, the sense of job security also appeals to me. I am in my late 40's now with a family, and just want to settle somewhere long-term. 

So anyway, I have been sent a large interview pack. It is unlike anything I have ever seen in the Private Sector. Still, I feel having so much detail will help me to prepare properly and fully represent myself. I am preparing answers according to the 'STAR model' and their stated values, and experience as outlined in the Success Factors methodology. 

My question is about the general style of interview and expectations. Are they looking for lengthy, conversational answers? What type of person fits the culture? Indeed, how much is culture a deciding factor? How are these things scored? I appreciate these are broad, vague questions - I guess I am just after some generic advice as I am not entirely sure what to expect. It all looks quite different from what I am used to. I would be grateful for any feedback - thank you!

13827 views
  • I moved from the private sector to local government eight years ago and have no regrets. It can be frustrating as some have mentioned and finances are stretched but I get tremendous job satisfaction as what we do really makes a difference to people's lives. For me, 'What is the best thing for the people we serve?' is a more energising question than 'How can we maximise return for our shareholders?'

    I've worked in a number of industries and didn't find the difference as large as some people have. Much depends on your previous experience and the organisation you're joining. If you have any contacts on LinkedIn that work there it would be worth asking out how they find it.

    In addition to previous advice I would make sure that you have a well-thought through answer to any questions around diversity. They'll be looking for personal commitment to it rather than generally thinking it's a good thing.

    Good luck with the interview!
  • Steve Bridger

    | 0 Posts

    Community Manager

    21 Mar, 2024 12:26

    In reply to Harriet :

    Thanks, Harriet. Really appreciating these shared experiences from those currently working in the public sector.

  • In reply to Elizabeth:

    Thanks, Elizabeth, that is excellent advice. I appreciate your input. The role is with an executive agency which works for a government department (not quite sure what that means!). I will take your advice into account, it is useful to get some views from within the sector. Thank you
  • In reply to Gemma:

    Thanks for sharing that, Gemma. Sounds mad! I think you summarise it well when you talk about companies being a poor fit. For me, the fit is everything. Otherwise, it is very hard to properly engage with a role.
  • In reply to Harriet :

    Thanks, Harriet for your insight, I appreciate it! I like the way you summarised the sense of job satisfaction. That is what I am looking for: a greater sense of purpose at work.
  • In reply to Chris:

    For a government department I would look at the structures, governance and policy frameworks for that agency.
  • Steve Bridger

    | 0 Posts

    Community Manager

    21 Mar, 2024 15:41

    In reply to Chris:

    This will be something like HM Prison Service (Home Office), the Environment Agency (Defra)... and will be key to understanding the relationships with those who would be your peers in the sponsoring Govt dept.
  • In reply to Steve Bridger:

    Thanks, Steve - I will take that into consideration. I appreciate the tip
  • In reply to Steven :

    Thanks, Steven, I appreciate it. Sounds like the right place to start. I will have a look
  • In reply to Chris:

    Thanks Chris - it sounds like there's a mismatch in your values and those of your organisation. It's great that you are looking at alternatives so that you can take this learning forward in your career. We often learn about what works and doesn't with people through our own personal and sometimes difficult situations. Good luck and do let us know how you get on :)
  • In reply to Jackie Allen:

    Thanks, Jackie, I will do - again, I really appreciate your advice on this one!
  • Hi Chris - I’m a little late commenting here and you may have already had some answers which have helped. Some of the cultural issues have been covered by other comments so I won’t go into it too much except to say that if you’ve some dealbreakers in the way you want to work or have a view about the kind of environment that is a fit for you then see if you can get a chat with the vacancy holder in advance. Often they will give a named contact so it might be worth a call. With regards the application on a very practical level you have the right approach using the Star formula as they will be looking for rounded examples of what you’ve done and the impact you’ve actually made. They will be expecting you to give examples to meet the essential criteria or the behaviours they have set out in the job spec. I was involved in recruitment a lot and one of the most frustrating aspects from good private sector candidates was their presumption that simply stating their job history, duties etc would be enough. They will score you on the examples you give matched against the criteria/behavior levels set out in the success factors. Hope that helps a little.
  • Steve Bridger

    | 0 Posts

    Community Manager

    27 Mar, 2024 07:09

    Very best for your interview today,  

  • Wishing you good luck with the interview/s Chris and you have lots of great advice here. I have moved across sectors and around and, although I'm not permanent anymore, I think having a job where you feel a sense of purpose and being valued can be found and can bring a pep back to our steps.

    I would expect the interview to be structured and competency based as there will be a focus on given a similar/ the same experience to all. My advise would be to approach it like you would any interview experience: research them thoroughly, prepare and pitch your experience to their needs, answer the questions and scan the room to see if you can get any clues on how those are going down and then adjust accordingly, be yourself and ask the questions you need to check if there is a match between your values/ needs/ wants and theirs.

    No one really knows what is a good fit for them until they work in a place and work can be frustrating and challenging, whatever the sector, but feeling a chemistry with you new potential colleagues and feeling the sense of a good fit is likely to be a good guide. All the best.
  • In reply to Sharon:

    Hi Sharon, thank you for for input. I take your point about the chemistry, as a means to gauge the fit. I had the interview the other day and I must say it was a very engaging experience. Everyone I met was delightful, very warm, and clearly passionate about what they do. If they offer, I think I would be likely to accept. It would actually mean taking a bit of a pay cut, but I feel it is the better move, long term.