7

Accessing racially offensive website

We received a complaint from an employee stating that a colleague sitting next to them are accessing a far right ethno-nationalist website on their computer on regular basis. Although the crux of this issue is the employee accessing potentially offensive website during work hours, using their work computer in breach of their computer use policy, it is not clear without doubt whether it is a serious breach or not - because it is not quite like the use of inappropriate websites, (chat rooms, online gambling, adult websites, illegal and criminal content etc.). 

We have blocked the said website immediately from our IT systems and we understand the importance of addressing it with the individual. However, would this necessarily trigger disciplinary action? 

It is quite a tricky situation. Would like to hear fellow HR colleagues view on this? 

406 views
  • Welcome to Community, Hasidi.

    You speak yourself of 'inappropriate' websites, and this is maybe borderline: the exact, actual content matters a great deal, perhaps - e.g. was it 'just' an instance of rather extreme political content or downright racist content that was indirectly potentially unlawful as likely to incite racial hatred or to cause offence (or worse) with others who happened to see it?

    The main thing is of course breach of your workplace computer use rules, irrespective of the actual content, save that it was unauthorised viewing albeit made worse if it was on view to colleagues etc and likely to cause offence and / or to bring employer into disrepute - e.g. clearly in similar category to soft porn or other salacious etc material.

    Unless such as one of the above things applied to the content, think it best not to act as censor or moral guardian and just to treat it as unspecified unauthorised / clearly non work -related content. But it's arguably different overall than someone merely looking briefly at their private email or buying something innocuous on eBay for their private domestic use, so maybe justifies action potentially involving formal disciplinary process - BUT , action based on breach of computer use rules.

    Sorry - sounds a bit like sitting on fence, but without the precise facts, it's very hard to say, IMHO.
  • In reply to David:

    Thank you David.

    Yes, as you have said it is a borderline case. I agree that it is more of a breach of the computer use policy rather than 'inappropriate' content because it is difficult to determine the inappropriateness of political views, contrary to criminal or clearly harmful websites.

    I am ending the thread because I have realised that I am unable to give more context into this issue..

    But, thank you for your advice. It is really useful to hear your point of view.
  • In reply to Hasini :

    If the said political site is not illegal, or supporting illegal views then I would only treat it as an abuse of your use in work time policy and unlikely to be more than a first warning for me.
  • In reply to Hasini :

    Hi Hasini, agree with Keith.
  • I don't think this has to be border line case. More importantly, much more importantly, you have a word, formal or informal, it doesn't matter, with the employee concerned and ask them what they were up to. You don't need to get muddled up with what 'rule' they broke to speak to someone.
  • just as a slight aside but taking into account recent events, would there not be some kind need to check the content of the site and potentially report concerns?
  • Steve Bridger

    | 0 Posts

    Community Manager

    20 Jun, 2017 10:34

    In reply to Annette:

    Good point, Annette.