4

Peri teachers - terminating old contracts and issuing new

Hi everyone,  I hope someone can advise me on this.  I work in HR for a multi academy trust for 5 schools.  We have a number of Peri music teachers who have been working with our schools part-time, some who have been with their schools for many years.  Their contracts are extremely old, all very different from each school from before they TUPE'd to the Trust, the contracts appear to be support style ones which do not mention any with the teachers pay and conditions, and their rates of pay are all very different, and not linked to any scale or range.  Some of the hourly rates are also extremely high and the working weeks are more than the Peris actually teach.  For instance some state they are paid for 44 weeks per year, when the teacher only delivers tuition for approx 39 weeks per year, in line with the school working weeks.  

We have been working with these teachers for the past couple of months to explain that the Trust cannot continue financially like this, explaining that the TUPE happened around 3 years ago and now is the right time to harmonise all contracts, and that we would like them to transfer to our Teacher contracts.  We have held a group consultation mtg and also 1-1 individual consultation meetings with them all, we permitted them to be accompanied at the 1-1 mtgs by a TU rep/work colleague.  We have already agreed to honour the hourly rates of pay.

Our contracts do not allow for collective agreements, we have a mobility clause included, and, whilst pay is spread out throughout the year, the payments will be linked to the academic working weeks.  This means that, although they will retain their current hourly rates as agreed, the actual working weeks will be reduced so effectively we make a saving and they will lose a proportion of their annual income.  We already know from the 1-1 mtgs that, although they all understand why we need to do this, none of them are happy about the proposed changes, so when the contracts are issued in the next few days and they will have further 1-1 mtgs with their line managers, we are not expecting any of them to agree to sign the new contracts.

I believe we have been open and transparent and have followed a fair consultation process.  I am also aware that, providing there is evidence that the employer has followed a fair process, a final option for the employer is to terminate the old contract and issue new contracts anyway, the following day.  I understand this is not ideal - and I have never done this before.

The problem at the moment is that, because of other reasons, unfortunately the process was delayed for around 6 weeks, and the current climate has delayed it even further.  I know the notice period for teachers is coming up at the end of May and I'm unclear as to - if we are going to have to terminate and re-issue new contracts, where do we stand with the teacher notice periods?  Does this conflict with the termination and re-issuing next day?  I really don't have a clue?  We are running out of time to link this in with the end of May notice period, to start with new contracts on 1st Sept - I'm feeling a bit lost now and really need some help if anyone can assist with what I can do, when etc. that would be great?

Many thanks

2096 views
  • I forgot to say, we are also reducing the minimum guaranteed working hours per school week (they will all be on a minimum of 2.5 hpw, and the contract states that they will be advised of the actual timetabled hours for the next academic year, once timetabling has been confirmed. The contract also states that the working hours can be adjusted throughout the year depending on the need. Their current contracts guaranteed minimum hours per week, which are all quite high; if we don't have the hours to give them, they continue to be paid at that higher rate, all very expensive. For instance, some are guaranteed to be paid 8-10 hpw yet, and before the lockdown, were only delivering tuition for 2-4 hpw.
  • In reply to Rosemary:

    Hi everyone,
    I posted the above a while ago. After a short spell where I was extremely busy with the lockdown/furlough etc I didn't continue with this process. (There is only me and one Assistant Head who are running this, under the direction of the CEO). Anyway, we've recently picked this up again and the staff have had further 1-1 remote meetings with their line managers supported by me and the Assistant Head. I have received questions and am putting together a Q&A sheet for them, and am doing a final check on the actual salaries to pass to them. Of the 10 staff, one person has so far agreed, signed and returned his contract. The rest are not happy due to the decrease in pay, although for all, it is quite small. To be clear, this is nothing to do with the TUPE of 3 years ago - it is for financial business reasons for the Trust going forwards. The deadline for their decisions is next Friday, although we have already said we are prepared to extend this for them if they feel they would like more time to consider. The start date for the new contracts is 1st Sept. If some do not sign the contracts, I am aware of the dismissal and re-engagement using SOSR. The CEO is keen to use this if necessary. I'm nervous because I have never had to use this before. I am confident the process has been fair, not rushed, although there were some complaints about the delay, and lack of information (information I wasn't aware of myself), I've found the answers and will respond.
    If the teacher refuses to sign and we then dismiss and re-engage (the following day), with teachers, what are the pitfalls? What should I be aware of? Can we do this with teachers who ordinarily are entitled to 3 month's notice at set times of the year?? Can someone please help with guidance? Many thanks!!
  • In reply to Rosemary:

    Hi Rosemary

    I’d think that it’s everything to do with the TUPE of three years ago, in that the very reason that they’re on these particular t and c which happen to be unpalatable to the employer is the TUPE transfer.

    Whilst protection of transferring contractual terms under TUPE isn't necessarily total forever, neither does it automatically fade away as time passes.

    Your employers might be well advised if they haven’t already to seek professional legal opinion from a TUPE specialist or at the very least one from the free CIPD legal helpline. My own opinion though for what it’s worth is that TUPE protection very much applies here.
  • In reply to David:

    Hi David, Thank you for that clarification. I'll contact CIPD legal for some advice on how this moves forward from here. Thanks again.